World

Why did Japan lose the Battle of the Coral Sea?

The Battle of the Coral Sea was the first of the five great naval aircraft carrier battles of the Pacific War. It was the first naval battle where neither opposing fleet came within sight of the other.

It was the first time USN wildcat fighters met the Imperial Japanese Navy’s (IJN) daunting Zero fighter in combat, and persevered. The two forces fielded approximately the same air strength: the USN had 141 combat aircraft on two carriers vs 147 aircraft on three IJN carriers.

Tactically, the Imperial Japanese Navy (IJN) won the naval battle of the Coral Sea; the USN fleet was the first to leave the battlefield.

The USN lost the large fleet aircraft carrier USS Lexington (CV 2) sunk and the USS Yorktown (CV 5) damaged. Also sunk were a fleet oiler and a destroyer. USN aircraft loses on May 8, 1942, were 56 combat aircraft (~40% total loss rate).

USS Lexington (CV 2) dead in the water, being abandoned, May 8, 1942

The Japanese, on the other hand, seem to have gotten off lightly, losing a light carrier, IJN Shoho, one destroyer and three minesweepers sunk. However, the IJN lost 69 combat aircraft, mostly from carrier Zuikaku (~47% total loss rate).

IJN light aircraft carrier Shoho, burning from bomb hits and struck by a torpedo, May 8, 1942

However, the two Japanese fleet carriers, Shokaku (bomb damage to her flight deck) and Zuikaku (her air group requiring reconstitution), both veterans of the Pearl Harbor raid, would return to Japan for repairs and replenishment of their depleted air groups.

Strategically the Japanese lost the Battle of the Coral Sea in two ways. First, their amphibious attempt to capture Port Moresby, a significant military objective on the southern coast of Papua New Guinea had been thwarted. Their seaborne failure compel the Japanese military to attempt a disastrous overland assault on Port Moresby; over the rugged Own Stanley Mountains where they were again turned back just short of their goal by determined Australian troops and mother nature.

Australian troops and natives porter on the “Trail of Death”, the Kokoda Track, July-Nov. 1942

Second, as a result of the Battle of the Coral Sea, two of the most modern IJN fleet carriers were unavailable to take part in the Battle of Midway, one month later. Instead of facing six Japanese carriers at Midway the USN triumphed over four, leading to the sinking of all.

The damaged Yorktown, speedily retuned to Peral Harbor for repairs and her air group reinforcement, was credited with the sinking of IJN aircraft carrier Soryu and assisting carrier USS Enterprise (CV-6) fliers in the sinking of Hiryu.

Bomb damaged and fired ravaged IJN carrier Hiryu, abandoned, before being torpedoed by Japanese escorts, June 5, 1942

Both naval battles demonstrated the USA’s resolve to stop Japanese aggression and expansion in early Pacific War.

Related Posts

If a U.S. Navy carrier battle group cannot defeat the Houthis in Yemen, how is it going to defeat China in the South China Sea?

A question barely answerable. Well, if a US Navy carrier battle group cannot defeat the Houthis in Yemen, how is it going to defeat, what, oh, Cuba in…

Is it true that nuclear submarines carry some gold, firearms, and antibiotics in a vault to enable crewmen to survive a nuclear apocalypse?

I served on two nuclear submarines during the Cold War. We did carry gold, firearm, and antibiotics. They weren’t in a vault, though. The gold was carried, or…

President Trump said that the British should give the Argentinians the Falklands because the USA is not going to protect the British from the Argentinians any longer. How long will it be before the British surrender to the Argentinians?

I see no evidence that Trump has said anything about the Falklands lately, let alone the laughable claim in the question. As it is, the US is not…

If North Korea fires an ICBM at the USA, how many minutes will it take to reach U.S. mainland? Within how many seconds will the U.S. detect it?

Any ballistic missile fired from the DPRK would be detected almost immediately by either US radar systems in South Korea, naval vessels in the Sea of Japan or…

Is it really true that there are 2 F-16s waiting with their engines running in case something violates the Washington, D.C., no fly zone?

There are F-16, F-15 and F-35 fighter jets sitting alert 24/7 guarding all the borders of the US. And yes alert jets are near Washington D.C. They don’t…

Trump’s hatred for Canada just keeps building. Now he threatens to throw them out of the Five Eyes.

Are the other Four Eyes even sharing with the US now that they openly side with Russia and North Korea? An American here. Until my retirement I was…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *