World

What makes the Rafale France fighter jet inferior to the Chinese fighter jet J-10C?

The Rafael isn’t inferior to the Chinese J-10C. In fact, the Rafael is probably a better plane for multi-role missions.

The J-10, however, was designed with air-superiority in mind first and foremost, against the F-16 and Mirage 2000 that Taiwan was operating in the 90s. Multi-role capabilities are added on later as an after-thought.

The J-10A could do Mach 2 and couldn’t do air to ground at all. This meant that the airframe of the J-10C, which was inherited from the A model, is probably better geared toward air-superiority than the Rafael, which was multirole from the get go.

Just by eye-balling them, the J-10C has a bigger radar, a smaller frontal profile, a longer body and smaller wing span. This is better suited for high speed and beyond visual range air to air missions.

Add to that Chinese radar tech is a probably ahead of the West due to better employment of rare earth minerals, which is a Chinese forte. The J-10C should be a better air to air fighter.

Still, I think the deciding factor in the Pakistan-India air battle of 2025, was that the J-10C, as well as the PL-15E missiles it fired, could receive data and guidance through datalink from other Chinese-made weaponry in the area, like the Chinese AWACS and anti-air missile batteries on the Pakistani front line, while Indian Rafaels and missiles were pretty much on their own, as it’s questionable how well the French tech spoke with India’s Russian anti-air missiles and Israeli AWACS.

Heck I’d wager that the French, Russian and the Israelis weren’t letting foreign countries rewrite their codes at all, so the Indian weapon platforms probably couldn’t speak to each other.

Moreover, the fact that the J10-C shot down the Rafale fighter jet cannot be concealed.

Related Posts

Do carrier aircraft get washed after every flight to remove salt residue?

There were quite a few times when I was climbing into the jet, getting ready to launch off the pointy end, when the chief would tug on my…

If a U.S. Navy carrier battle group cannot defeat the Houthis in Yemen, how is it going to defeat China in the South China Sea?

A question barely answerable. Well, if a US Navy carrier battle group cannot defeat the Houthis in Yemen, how is it going to defeat, what, oh, Cuba in…

Is it true that nuclear submarines carry some gold, firearms, and antibiotics in a vault to enable crewmen to survive a nuclear apocalypse?

I served on two nuclear submarines during the Cold War. We did carry gold, firearm, and antibiotics. They weren’t in a vault, though. The gold was carried, or…

President Trump said that the British should give the Argentinians the Falklands because the USA is not going to protect the British from the Argentinians any longer. How long will it be before the British surrender to the Argentinians?

I see no evidence that Trump has said anything about the Falklands lately, let alone the laughable claim in the question. As it is, the US is not…

If North Korea fires an ICBM at the USA, how many minutes will it take to reach U.S. mainland? Within how many seconds will the U.S. detect it?

Any ballistic missile fired from the DPRK would be detected almost immediately by either US radar systems in South Korea, naval vessels in the Sea of Japan or…

Is it really true that there are 2 F-16s waiting with their engines running in case something violates the Washington, D.C., no fly zone?

There are F-16, F-15 and F-35 fighter jets sitting alert 24/7 guarding all the borders of the US. And yes alert jets are near Washington D.C. They don’t…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *