World

Why did communism fail everywhere except in China?

Because Communism failed in China before it did anywhere else.

Great leap forward, 20–100 million dead

Communism failed China so badly it was as relevant to the world stage as perhaps Pakistan is today: a nuisance for the neighbors perhaps, but not more. Yet China wanted more, it wanted to become the leader of the Communist world.

When it became clear the Soviets would have none of that they had to make a choice: either accept Soviet dominance and submit to the Russian Communist Party, or open up with the USA and change.

They did the sensible thing.

Nixon in China

China remained nominally Communist but in practice they’ve been anything but since 1970s. Their system right now most resembles that of 1920s Italy or 1930s Germany, which is many things, but even ardent anti-Communists would agree it is not Communism.


A famous political joke goes as such:

The American came to two roads that lead to 2 places. One sign reads “communism”, and the other one read “capitalism”, and went straight to “capitalism”.

Stalin came around, and went straight to “Communism”.

Then Chairman Deng came around, switched the signs, and went towards the one that read “Communism”.

The truth about The Market, is that neither totally free or totally controlled market would ever work. The U.S.S.R. and the U.S. have proven that. Completely free markets result in Social Darwinism: the rich get richer, and the poor get poorer.

Completely controlled markets lead to the opposite of control: complete hunger and lower life standards. China took the road down the middle. It’s hard, for anybody, or China, in this case. Economics has never been easy.

China is currently carefully balancing between “control” and “free market”. A slight lean towards one side may cause a lot of problems.

Related Posts

Is Donald Trump as beloved around the world as he is in the US?

I’ve been to about 65 countries and territories around the world (depending on how you count them), and all seven continents over the last several years. I’ve had…

If Japan had destroyed America’s aircraft carriers and oil reserves during Pearl Harbor, could they have won WWII?

No In Fact, I would postulate that Japan would have had it much worse. The U.S. Pacific fleet was moved from California to Pearl Harbor by Roosevelt in…

Why would Trump pick an idiot like Pete Hegseth as the Secretary of Defense?

Pete Hegseth proclaimed in the meeting with the U.S. top brass: “I don’t want my son serving alongside troops who are out of shape or in combat units…

What are the odds of a military coup against trump?

We already had one, though people don’t like to call it a coup. It was more the Joint Chiefs having the military remain in their barracks even though…

When Trump dies, will there be mass celebrations in America? Other than MAGA events, will anyone mourn Trump’s death?

When Trump dies I will get to the local supermarket and Make sure I have enough supplies to last me 10 days. Then I will lock my doors…

What are the odds of a military coup against trump?

We already had one, though people don’t like to call it a coup. It was more the Joint Chiefs having the military remain in their barracks even though…